Guides · Pricing problem: The legacy customer who was never raised
How much to raise a customer you haven't raised in years
The customer you can't afford at that price
Mrs. Patterson has been with you since 2019. She pays $45 a visit, on time, every time; she has never complained, and you have never raised her price.
Conventional wisdom states that a customer like her is the backbone of the business. But the numbers show a different story. Prices overall have risen 32% since 2019, so her $45 now buys you what $34 bought back then. And raising her with inflation would not have been enough: between 2016 and 2025, consumer prices rose 34%, while median pay rose 49% for landscaping workers and 63% for house cleaners.
I've spent my career building data teams, and I built WellPriced to find the underpriced customers in the books of lawn care and cleaning businesses. For this article I went to the public record (mostly the Bureau of Labor Statistics) to put numbers on a problem most owners feel but rarely measure.
The problem
A price that never changes is a price that falls. Your wages, fuel, insurance and equipment cost more every year; the invoice to a legacy customer (one whose price was set years ago and never revisited) stays the same. In real terms she pays you a little less each season.
Why do the longest-standing customers end up with the lowest prices? I believe two feelings and one mechanism explain most of it. The feelings are loyalty (she stayed with you when you were small, and raising her feels ungrateful) and fear (she is reliable income, and nobody wants to disturb that). The mechanism is simpler: a new customer gets today's price automatically, while an existing customer's price only changes if you act.
Nothing forces the decision. So it doesn't get made.
What it costs you
Take her $45 visit, set in 2019, at 30 visits a year. The customer is made up; the inflation figures behind the math are real.
To buy today what $45 bought in 2019, the price would need to be about $59.41. That is a shortfall of $14.41 on every visit, or about $432 a year on one customer. If you have 20 customers like her, you are giving up roughly $8,600 a year.
The hit to profit is sharper than the hit to revenue. Suppose that visit earned a 10% margin in 2019: $40.50 of cost and $4.50 of profit. If your costs rose only with inflation (they likely rose faster; see Finding 2), the same visit now costs about $53.47 to deliver. At $45 you lose roughly $8.47 every time the crew shows up.
She went from profitable to a loss. Nothing on the invoice changed.
The facts
A word on where the numbers come from. For prices I use the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U, the standard measure of what households pay), published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and pulled via FRED, the St. Louis Fed's database. For pay I use the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics survey. The percentages and dollar conversions are my own arithmetic; every source is linked.
Finding 1: A frozen price has lost between 5% and 41% of its value
The table shows what happened to prices since each year. Read it like this: if you last set a price in 2019, prices overall have risen 32.0% since, and a $50 visit would need to be $66.01 to buy what it bought then.
| Price last set in | Inflation that year | Price rise since, through Oct 2026 | A $50 visit should now be |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 1.3% | 40.6% | $70.31 |
| 2017 | 2.1% | 37.7% | $68.85 |
| 2018 | 2.4% | 34.4% | $67.20 |
| 2019 | 1.8% | 32.0% | $66.01 |
| 2020 | 1.2% | 30.4% | $65.20 |
| 2021 | 4.7% | 24.6% | $62.28 |
| 2022 | 8.0% | 15.3% | $57.66 |
| 2023 | 4.1% | 10.8% | $55.38 |
| 2024 | 2.9% | 7.6% | $53.80 |
| 2025 | 2.6% | 4.8% | $52.42 |
What surprised me was the quiet years. Prices rose about 6.5% between 2016 and 2019, before anyone was talking about inflation. The 2021 to 2023 stretch did the most damage; prices climbed roughly 18% in three years.
Finding 2: Pay rose faster than prices
Matching inflation only gets you to the floor. In both trades, the pay of the people doing the work rose faster than prices in general.
| May of | Landscaping workers, median hourly pay | Rise since 2016 | House cleaners, median hourly pay | Rise since 2016 | Consumer prices, rise since 2016 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | $12.65 | $10.49 | |||
| 2017 | $13.31 | 5% | $10.99 | 5% | 2% |
| 2018 | $13.94 | 10% | $11.43 | 9% | 5% |
| 2019 | $14.63 | 16% | $11.95 | 14% | 7% |
| 2020 | $15.26 | 21% | $12.61 | 20% | 7% |
| 2021 | $16.55 | 31% | $13.84 | 32% | 12% |
| 2022 | $17.26 | 36% | $14.40 | 37% | 22% |
| 2023 | $17.96 | 42% | $16.08 | 53% | 27% |
| 2024 | $18.31 | 45% | $16.66 | 59% | 31% |
| 2025 | $18.82 | 49% | $17.07 | 63% | 34% |
So a customer you raised exactly in line with inflation since 2016 is still behind. Her price is up 34%; the median pay of the person doing the work is up 49% in lawn care and 63% in cleaning. Wages are also only part of the labor bill, because payroll taxes and workers' compensation are charged on top of them and rise with them.
Finding 3: The going rate moved too
Your competitors did not stand still. One analysis of the BLS price index for gardening and lawn care services reports that what households pay roughly doubled in the ten years to September 2026, against about 40% for prices overall (Start Business by State, citing BLS series CUUR0000SEHP02). My interpretation is that a legacy customer is behind your costs and even further behind what a new customer on the same street pays you.
Finding 4: Most owners raise prices, and most customers stay
Raising prices is normal. In Jobber's survey of 1,050 home service owners (fielded in December 2025), 65% said they raised prices in the past year. Cleaning was the lowest trade at 55%; businesses under $100K in revenue came in at 54% (Jobber, 2026 Home Service Trends Report).
Small increases rarely draw objections. Jeff Allison of Allison Outdoor in Eastpointe, Michigan held maintenance prices for years, then raised contracts 10% in 2022 and 5% the year after. He told Lawn & Landscape that clients seldom balk at an increase under 5% if you explain it (March 2025).
Pushback tends to come from a handful of customers. Thomas Fancher of The Plant Concierge in Dallas raised maintenance rates about 10% over three years; four or five of his 150-plus customers objected (Lawn & Landscape, October 2015).
Price is also the strongest profit lever you have. McKinsey found that a 1% price increase lifts operating profit by 8.7% on average if volume holds (McKinsey). That study covers large companies, but the arithmetic works the same way for a small one: at a 10% margin, a 5% increase that loses no customers raises profit by half.
How to spot it in your own book
Four signs point to legacy pricing:
- Same job, different prices: two similar properties on the same street, and the older customer pays noticeably less.
- Round, old-looking numbers: prices like $35 or $40 that you stopped quoting years ago.
- No record of a change: you cannot say when a customer's price last moved.
- Prices set in 2022 or earlier: anyone not raised since then is at least 15% behind inflation; those priced before 2021 are 30% or more behind.
But start date and price alone will mislead you. A long-time customer with a small lot on a tight route can still be one of your best earners per labor hour, while a newer customer at a higher price loses money on the drive. What matters is revenue per labor hour (what a visit pays divided by the crew hours it takes, drive included), and working that out takes visit and time data lined up customer by customer.
That is the part most owners never get to.
Ways to fix it, with trade-offs
There is no free option here; each fix trades speed against risk.
One catch-up increase. You move the customer to today's rate in a single step, and the loss stops this season. The risk is the size of the jump: 25% - 30% is the kind of increase customers notice, and a loyal customer may feel ambushed.
Staged increases. You close the gap over two or three seasons, so each step is small enough to explain. You also keep subsidizing the customer in the meantime, and your costs keep rising while you catch up. Still, each step shrinks the subsidy and brings the customer closer to profitable.
A yearly increase for everyone. You make a small annual adjustment standard and put it in writing. Phil Schoggen of SchoggenScapes in Mississippi ties the increases in his three-year contracts to the Consumer Price Index, so clients can see their worst case in advance (Lawn & Landscape). This stops today's customers from drifting into underpriced legacy customers; it does nothing for a gap that already exists.
Change the service, keep the price. You reduce frequency or scope until the price fits the work. That helps a customer on a fixed budget stay, but you earn less per customer and the property may look worse.
Keep the price on purpose. Some customers earn their rate through referrals or by anchoring a dense route. This only works as a decision you made with the cost known.
Part ways. A last resort, for customers who lose money at any price they will accept.
Any one of these is manageable for a single customer. Across a book of 150, the hard questions are which customers, in what order, and by how much - without raising the ones who already pay their way.
What this data can't tell you
It's important to call out that these are national figures. Your market, your wages and your competitors may have moved more or less than the averages in the tables.
The Consumer Price Index tracks what households pay for everything; it was never built to track a lawn care or cleaning company's costs. The wage survey is a yearly snapshot, and BLS changed how it estimates the figures in 2021 (BLS notice), so read the trend and ignore single-year jumps. It also covers employees only (owner-operators are left out).
The accounts of how customers reacted come from two trade articles, one of them from 2015. They are stories from individual owners. I don't yet have enough data of my own to say how customers respond to a given increase. I plan to publish that once I do, from anonymized numbers combined across at least 10 companies (how we handle your data).
Next step
You can check one customer right now: the free revenue per labor hour calculator shows what a visit earns you per hour, drive included.
Have you raised a long-time customer recently? If so - I'd like to hear how it went. Tell me about it.
Questions owners ask
How much should I raise a customer who has not had an increase in years?
Use the inflation table as the floor: find the year you last set the price. Then check it against the labor the visit takes, because wages rose faster than inflation.
How often should I raise prices?
Once a year. In Jobber's survey, 65% of owners raised prices in the past year, and I am convinced that small yearly increases are easier on customers than a large one every five years.
Will I lose customers?
Probably a few. The owners quoted in this guide heard objections from a small share of their customers (four or five out of 150 in one case). Losing a customer who costs you money on every visit can improve your profit.
Is inflation the right yardstick?
It is the minimum. Your costs are mostly labor, and labor rose faster.
More pricing problems
- Should you charge more for far-away customers? What drive time costs
- Scope creep in lawn care and cleaning: what extra minutes cost you
- Weekly vs. biweekly pricing: how big a discount can you afford?
- Flat-rate pricing for big properties: when your biggest invoice pays least
- One-person or two-person crew: what the second person costs
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index (CPI-U), via FRED series CPIAUCNS
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025 federal government shutdown impact on the CPI
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, data tables by year
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers, May 2023
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners, May 2023
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, new estimation methodology from the May 2021 estimates
- Start Business by State, Lawn care prices (BLS series CUUR0000SEHP02)
- Jobber, 2026 Home Service Trends Report
- Lawn & Landscape, High maintenance (March 2025)
- Lawn & Landscape, raising prices and profits (October 2015)
- McKinsey, Using big data to make better pricing decisions