Guides · Pricing problem: The two-person crew on a one-person job
One-person or two-person crew: what the second person costs
The second person is only free if the job takes half the time
A $100 lawn that one person can finish in 40 minutes earns $150 per labor hour (what the visit pays divided by the crew hours on site). Send two people, and it stays at $150 only if they are done in 20 minutes. If they take 28, the same lawn earns $107.14 per labor hour. If the second person mostly waits by the truck, it earns $75.
Conventional wisdom states that the two-person crew is the efficient one; in a Lawn & Landscape poll, 55% of respondents named it the ideal size for residential mowing. But that is an answer about the route. The numbers show a different story at the single stop, where two people rarely cut the time in half.
I built WellPriced to find stops like this one in the books of lawn care and cleaning businesses. For this article I worked out what the second person costs at different levels of teamwork, and looked at what contractors have said on the record about crew size.
The problem
You price a job by the job: the lawn, the house. You staff it by the route: whoever is on the truck that day. So a small property on a two-person route gets two people, at a price that assumed nothing about how many would show up.
Two people do finish faster than one. The question is whether they finish in half the time. On a large open property they can work side by side the whole visit. On a small one, they can't. On a small lawn there is one mower's worth of grass; the second person trims, and then waits. In a small apartment there is one bathroom and one kitchen; the second cleaner runs out of rooms.
I believe this is rarely a decision. Crew size is set for the biggest jobs on the route, and the small stops inherit it.
What it costs you
The examples are made up; the wage rates are real.
Take the $100 lawn. One person needs 40 minutes, which is two thirds of a labor hour. Two people who finish in 28 minutes use 56 minutes of labor between them: 16 minutes more. At the median pay for landscaping workers ($18.82 an hour in May 2025), that is $5.02 a visit, or $150.56 over 30 visits.
Now a $160 clean that one person can do in two hours. Two people who finish in an hour and 24 minutes have used 2.8 labor hours. At the $17.07 median for house cleaners, the extra 0.8 hours costs $13.66 a visit; over 26 visits that is $355.06.
And the drive counts double. Every minute between stops is paid twice on a two-person crew, whatever the size of the next job.
The facts
A word on where the numbers come from. Wages are from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics survey. The contractor accounts are from Lawn & Landscape. The tables are my own arithmetic, and every source is linked.
Finding 1: Unless two people halve the time, the second one costs you
The table shows what happens when two people do a job one person could do. The first column is how long the pair takes, as a share of the solo time: 50% means they halved it, 100% means the second person added nothing.
| Two people finish in | Labor hours used | $100 lawn, revenue per labor hour | $100 lawn, extra wages paid over 30 visits | $160 clean, extra wages paid over 26 visits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One person alone | as planned | $150.00 | $0 | $0 |
| 50% of the solo time | the same | $150.00 | $0 | $0 |
| 60% | 20% more | $125.00 | $75.28 | $177.53 |
| 70% | 40% more | $107.14 | $150.56 | $355.06 |
| 80% | 60% more | $93.75 | $225.84 | $532.58 |
| 100% | double | $75.00 | $376.40 | $887.64 |
The middle rows are the realistic ones. A pair that finishes in 70% of the solo time feels fast on site (the job took 28 minutes instead of 40). It still used 40% more labor.
Finding 2: Contractors themselves say bigger crews waste time
In the Lawn & Landscape poll, 55% of respondents picked two-person crews as ideal for residential mowing, 28% picked three, 12% four or more, and 5% one (Lawn & Landscape).
The comments under the numbers are more telling. Mike Mitchell of Signature Landscape in Olathe, Kansas said his time studies showed a three-person crew is no more productive than a two-person one. Mike Lueders of Lueders Cos. in Needham, Massachusetts went further: even a second person, he argued, costs time on a job. His rule of thumb was one worker for a job of six to eight labor hours.
In an April 2008 feature, Shayne Newman of YardApes in New Milford, Connecticut said his company ruled out three-person crews early, because they led to too many inefficiencies on the job site. A one-person crew, he added, may suit small sites, though many workers prefer not to work alone (Lawn & Landscape, April 2008).
Finding 3: Crew size is usually set by labor hours, when it is set at all
The contractors who do decide crew size tend to use budgeted hours. Jim Thorpe of The "J" Boys in Pennsauken, New Jersey sends a two-person team to mowing jobs budgeted under six labor hours, and three-person crews above 16 (same April 2008 feature).
By that yardstick, a 40-minute lawn is far below the size where a second person earns their place.
These sources are about lawn care, and some are old. I found nothing comparable for cleaning. The arithmetic in Finding 1 does not depend on the trade.
How to spot it in your own book
Four signs point to an overstaffed stop:
- Small job, full crew: your shortest stops get the same headcount as your longest.
- One person waiting: the crew lead will tell you which stops have one person standing by the truck.
- Low earnings on a fair price: a stop that is priced like its neighbors but earns less per labor hour.
- A route built around one big job: the crew size fits the largest property and nothing else on the day.
But crew size alone will mislead you. Two people on a small job can be the right call when it sits between two large ones; pulling a person off for 25 minutes costs more than it saves. What counts is the labor hours each stop takes with the crew it gets, set against what it would take with one.
That comparison needs the same property visited both ways, or good time records. Most owners have neither.
Ways to fix it, with trade-offs
None of these is a price change at first; the staffing comes before the price.
Run a solo route for the small stops. You group the jobs one person can do and send one person. It is the direct fix. It needs a second vehicle and equipment set, and the route stops if that one person is out sick.
Split the crew on site. One person does the small job while the other starts the neighbor's. It costs nothing and works well on a dense street. It only works where two customers are within walking distance.
Set crew size by budgeted hours. Like Jim Thorpe, you decide in advance which jobs get one, two or three people. It takes a time budget for every job, which you may not have yet.
Price the stop for the crew it gets. If a property will always be served by two people, you price it on the labor hours two people use. The customer pays for your staffing choice, and a competitor with a solo operator may quote less.
Set a minimum price per stop. A floor that covers two people for the shortest visit plus the drive. It protects the small stops; some small-property customers will not pay it.
Any one of these is manageable for a single stop. Across a whole book, you first have to know which stops are using more labor than the job needs.
What this data can't tell you
It's important to call out the age and reach of the contractor accounts. The poll carries no date, the interviews are from 2008, and all of it is lawn care. Crews and equipment have changed since.
The percentages in my table are scenarios. I have no measured figure for how much faster two people finish a given job than one, and it will differ by property.
The table counts wages on site only. A second person also brings things it leaves out: safety, cover when someone is sick, and a route that does not stop when one person does.
I don't yet have enough data of my own to say what happens to earnings when an owner moves small stops to a solo route. I plan to publish that once I do, from anonymized numbers combined across at least 10 companies (how we handle your data).
Next step
You can check one stop right now: enter the price, the crew size and the minutes on site into the free revenue per labor hour calculator, then change the crew size and the minutes to see what a solo visit would earn.
Have you moved small stops to a solo route, or split a crew on site? If so - I'd like to hear how it went. Tell me about it.
Questions owners ask
Is a two-person crew a mistake?
No. For a full route it was the most popular choice in the poll. The cost shows up at the small stops, where two people cannot both be busy.
How do I know if two people halve the time?
Send one person to the same property once and compare the minutes. If the pair takes more than half the solo time, the second person is costing you labor there.
Should I charge more because I send two people?
Only if you intend to keep sending two. Otherwise fix the staffing first.
Does this apply to cleaning?
The arithmetic does. A two-hour solo clean done by two people in an hour and 24 minutes uses 2.8 labor hours.
More pricing problems
- How much to raise a customer you haven't raised in years
- Should you charge more for far-away customers? What drive time costs
- Scope creep in lawn care and cleaning: what extra minutes cost you
- Weekly vs. biweekly pricing: how big a discount can you afford?
- Flat-rate pricing for big properties: when your biggest invoice pays least